Under the chairmanship of Mr. Gamaliel Onosode, the forum
was an initiative of Olisa Agbakoba and Associates which
also used the forum to make a public presentation on their
pioneering publication on bankruptcy proceedings, a Practice
Text. Panelists included Professor Isabella Okagbue, Company
Secretary and Legal Adviser of United Bank for Africa, UBA,
Agbakoba, SAN, Mr. Ayo Ogunyinka of Credit Risk Managers
Association CREMA, Dr. Atoki, Vice Chairman, Chartered Institute
of Arbitrators, Ms. Funke Aboyade, General Counsel, THISDAY
Newspapers and Mr. Kehinde Aina of the NCMG.
Onosode's opening remarks were quite incisive and apt as
he captured the very essence of the forum. In a lighter
mood, he regretted not having had the opportunity to have
practiced universal banking having retired 24 years ago
from his many years of banking. Onosode however advocated
a system that is intrinsically strong enough to punish deviant
behaviour in bank credit transactions. He is of the opinion
that part of the bad debts in the industry today were deliberately
created by bankers themselves.
He therefore recommended a law that will look at both the
borrower and the creditor.
Okagbue's presentation viewed the issues in bankruptcy
and debt recovery from a banker's perspective. In her opinion,
the most crucial issue is the recovery of non performing
loans. Her greatest worries are first, that credit is not
just available at the low end of the banking spectrum because
we operate a cash economy and the cash is not just there.
Secondly, though genuine failure of businesses does occur,
people go to banks to borrow money without any intention
of ever paying back and with the collusion of officials.
Ogunyinka reeled out frightening figures on debt portfolios
in the banking industry. He drew the attention of participants
to the fact that risk portfolios were on the increase until
recently when the CBN reluctantly stepped in. It was an
eye opener that non performing loans constitute 20% of total
loan portfolios which translates to 1/5 of all loans have
a tendency to be lost completely. He found it rather disheartening
that the total debt profile in the country and the total
national budget are almost at par with debts at N680 billion
and budget at N800 billion in the year 2001.
The book presentation by Mr. Inam Wilson took participants
through the nitty-gritty of bankruptcy proceedings including
a checklist which he said lawyers will find invaluable.
The book itself is a practice handbook on the subject matter
and was highly praised by lawyers as a pioneering effort
in the field. Mr. Wilson succintly pointed out a lacuna
in the bankruptcy Act which allows only a second line charge
in bankruptcy proceedings.
That branckruptcy proceedings can only be commenced only
after getting a court judgment.
Agbakoba, SAN's presentation painted an alarming picture
of the situation. He warned of a systemic failure in the
banking industry and that it requires very aggressive tools
to solve. The fact that the existing legal frame work has
not really changed in the last 100 years has not helped
matters.
The learned Senior Advocate summed up his presentation
by recommending compulsory legal audits of loans in all
banks and the insertion of ADR clause in loan agreements.
His recommendation of legislation to take care of the yawning
gaps in banking transaction enjoyed the overwhelming support
of participants even as he regrets that Universal banking,
consumer credit and many other banking transactions have
no legal backing.
Mr. Kehinde Aina handled the Alternative despite Resolution
angle of the forum. he believes that bank licences should
not just be revoked for erring banks, but that officials
of such banks should be prosecuted. His only regret however
was that most banks have no regards for their legal department.
The forum ended with a very exciting and engaging interactive
session.
It was unanimously accepted that all banks should pull
resources and mobilise Agbakoba, SAN to sponsor a private
member Bill at the National Assembly on the subject matter
as a matter of ingency. Tributes were paid to the Chairman
of the event Onosode who many proclaimed as their living
Nigerian heroe having distinguished himself in public service
by an untainted record.